Skip to main content

News story

September 28, 2018

The Employment Tribunal Strikes Back

A pilot who provided a fake reference from a Star Wars villain has been ordered to repay his training costs

An Employment Tribunal has ordered a pilot to repay £4,725 in training costs after it emerged that he provided a fake reference using the name of a character from Star Wars – Mr Desilijic Tiure.

For those of us who are not Star Wars fans, this is another name for the slug-like character Jabba the Hutt, the de facto leader of the Desilijic-Hutt Cartel.

In the case of Francis-McGann v West Atlantic UK Limited, it transpired that not only had the pilot, Mr Francis-McGann, given a false reference from the Star Wars character but had also lied about his employment history, claiming to have worked as a Captain when in fact he had only occupied the position of First Officer.

When the pilot was challenged by his employers, he initially denied such claims but ultimately largely admitted them. The pilot was then offered the opportunity to resign by West Atlantic, which he did “with immediate effect”.

Subsequently, the pilot made a claim against West Atlantic for three months’ notice pay, being his contractual entitlement had he resigned with notice rather than “with immediate effect”. West Atlantic therefore counter-claimed for the recovery of his training costs.

In a damning decision, Judge Broughton dismissed the pilot’s claim for notice pay, stating:

“…the meaning of the words “with immediate effect” is clear and unambiguous. As a result, the claimant must have known what he was agreeing to.”

Regarding West Atlantic’s counterclaim Judge Broughton concluded:

“The claimant had expressly confirmed in writing by a credit agreement… that such [training] costs were recoverable should his employment end within the first six months.”

As a further warning, the Tribunal indicated that it had considered making a costs order against the pilot.

It is perhaps an extreme example of the need for honesty by employees when it comes to references, but as Jabba the Hutt’s history might have shown, dishonesty really doesn’t pay.

For employment advice and information, call solicitor Karen Cole today.

Note: This article is not legal advice; it provides information of general interest about current legal issues.

Stay in touch

Subscribe to our newsletter

Stay in touch

By completing your details and submitting this form you confirm you are happy for us to send you marketing communications and that you agree to our Website Privacy Policy and Legal Notice and to us using Mailchimp to process your data.


Sending

News/Insight

  • Strategic lifetime gifting
    How to minimise your IHT liability during your lifetime.


    Read more
  • Navigating directors’ duties
    Legal responsibilities and risks for UK company directors


    Read more
  • Preparing a business-lasting power of attorney
    In this article, private client solicitor Herman Cheung of West End law firm RIAA Barker Gillette (UK) considers the advantages, needs and practical examples of creating a bu


    Read more
  • Can you make a WhatsApp will?
    Key legal requirements and future outlook.


    Read more
  • Supporting neurodiverse people in family law matters
    Understanding neurodiversity in the legal context.


    Read more

What they say...

  • Michael, May 2025
    “Very pleased with the services provided by Charlotte Barbaroussis. Particularly found her quick and effective to reply to any queries.”

  • Malcolm & Sheila Blackmore, May 2025
    “My wife and I engaged RIAA Barker Gillette to prepare our wills and LPOA’s. James McMullan and Charlotte Barbaroussis were the epitome of professionalism – responding quickly, talking us through the legalese, clearly answering any

  • Ian, April 2025
    “Martin and his team at Barker Gillette acted for us in our purchase and sale of property. The chain was lengthy and elements of the work became complex. Martin was tenacious and resolved to answer our queries as they arose. He handled all aspe

  • Henry, April 2025
    “We have purchased flats before with 2 different solicitors who were unable to help us this time. Martin came highly recommended and are we glad. He was very professional in every way: knowledgeable, approachable, he has a friendly manner, very

  • Megan Purcell-Jones, April 2025
    “Charlotte was extremely diligent and thorough. She talked us through the process of making our wills and listened to and understood our needs and the complexities involved. Extremely patient and very clear.”

Read more
Send this to a friend